Independent Insurance for Pennsylvania Families, Farms, and Businesses

Your Community Insurance Partner Since 1945

Mylet & Musselman Insurance Group has been helping generations of Pennsylvania residents find the right coverage for their homes, cars, farms, and businesses. With office locations in Gettysburg and Mountain Top, we combine local expertise with access to a wide range of national carriers—so you’re never limited to a single option.


Unlike national chains with 1-800 numbers, our agents work and live in the same communities we serve. Whether you're calling about home insurance in Hanover or need help filing a claim after a storm, you'll talk to someone who knows your area—and your needs.

Our Services

Whether you're buying your first home or growing your small business, we're here to help you protect what matters. Our independent model allows us to shop coverage from multiple carriers, comparing rates and features so you don’t have to.

We offer support with:

For drivers of all ages

For houses, condos, and rental properties

Tailored to rural operations

For small to mid-size enterprises

Brick courthouse with a white clock tower under a blue sky, flags and a fountain in foreground.

What Makes Us Different

You’ll never get stuck in a phone tree here. Every policy is handled by a real agent who’s focused on your priorities—not a corporate script. Mylet & Musselman clients know they can call or walk into the office and get answers from someone who’s actually familiar with their file.


We’ve been family-run since 1945, with a long-standing reputation in Adams County and Luzerne County for treating clients like neighbors. It’s why our Gettysburg insurance office has earned 5-star reviews and our Mountain Top team has been voted best in town four years running.

Local Service, Statewide Strength

From apple orchards near Biglerville to new construction homes across Mountain Top, we understand the risks and realities Pennsylvania families face. And because we’re independent, we’re free to place your policy with the carrier that best fits your needs—without being locked into one provider.


We serve clients throughout:

  • Adams County, including Gettysburg, Fairfield, and Littlestown
  • York County, including Hanover and New Oxford
  • Luzerne County, including Mountain Top and Wilkes-Barre
A blue and white triangle on a white background.

What Our Clients Are Saying

Jillian and her team are always great to deal with. Any questions I have on my policies are quickly answered or responded to. In this current insurance market, it is great to have this level of customer service and assistance with any policy needs. I couldn’t recommend Jillian and her team more.

Kyle H.

Luzerne County

My experience with your office has been wonderful. My experience with Farmers Fire has not. I find them difficult to deal with. The only saving grace has been working with Joy. She has always answered my questions and solved my problems. She is delightful to work with and I can always count on her to calm my fears and make everything right!! She is a true asset to your company.

Judie M.

Biglerville

Mylet & Musselman Insurance has been providing me excellent customer service with complete satisfaction for over a decade. I can say without question that the service they provide is unmatched. I highly recommend them for all of your insurance needs!

Frank L.

Hanover