A Local Insurance Agency Built on Relationships, Not Call Centers

A black and white drawing of a scale of justice on a white background.

Our Story

Mylet & Musselman Insurance Group has been a trusted name in Pennsylvania insurance for nearly 80 years. What began as a small, family-run agency in Gettysburg has grown into a multi-location business serving rural and urban communities alike—with the same focus on personalized care that started it all in 1945.


Ownership passed from father to son and eventually to our current leadership in 2013, keeping the business rooted in family values and community ties. Whether you’ve been with us for decades or just moved to the area, you’ll always get the kind of service that puts people ahead of policies.

Group of people outside a law office; the sign reads

What We Believe

We believe insurance should feel human. That’s why we don’t outsource phone calls or hide behind digital walls. When you call Mylet & Musselman, you speak directly with an agent—someone who listens, explains your options, and helps you make the right decision for your life.


We’re proud to serve clients from Gettysburg to Mountain Top, and we’ve built our reputation on trust, honesty, and real results.

A blue and white triangle on a white background.

Meet the Team

At the heart of our agency is a team of dedicated insurance professionals. We’re not just licensed experts—we’re also your neighbors, involved in local events, schools, and community programs.

A person with shoulder-length blonde hair, wearing a black sleeveless top, smiles while leaning against a white wall.
A person with shoulder-length hair smiles in a head-and-shoulders portrait, wearing a black top against a gray background.
A person with blonde hair, blue eyes, and a pleasant smile, wearing a pink top against a neutral gray background.
A person with dark hair smiling at the camera, wearing a black top, with their arms crossed, set against a gray background.
A person with long brown hair smiling against a plain white background, wearing a black long-sleeved shirt.

Recognized and Respected in Our Communities

Our commitment to personal service hasn’t gone unnoticed. Mylet & Musselman’s Mountain Top office has been voted Insurance Agency of Mountain Top four years in a row. We've also received a local customer service award recognizing our consistent 5-star reviews and client satisfaction.


We’re honored by this recognition—but even more proud that it reflects how our clients feel when they work with us.

Why Clients Choose Us

  • We offer access to multiple carriers for independent comparison shopping
  • You’ll speak directly to an agent—not a phone system or outsourced rep
  • We know Pennsylvania’s risks, regulations, and coverage gaps firsthand
  • Offices in both Gettysburg and Mountain Top for regional convenience
  • Nearly 80 years of continuous service with a family-first approach