What Our Clients Say About Working With Mylet & Musselman

Local Trust, Earned One Policy at a Time

Since 1945, Mylet & Musselman Insurance Group has grown through referrals, word-of-mouth, and strong relationships. Our clients don’t just stay with us—they send their friends, neighbors, and family members, too.


We’re proud to be known for personal attention, straightforward communication, and hands-on support when it matters most. Whether it’s helping a new driver get coverage or guiding a business owner through a claim, our priority is always the same: do what’s best for the client, not the carrier.

Group of people outside a law office; the sign reads

Consistently 5-Star Rated in Gettysburg and Mountain Top

Our team has earned:

  • Over 45 verified Google reviews with a 5-star average
  • “Best Insurance Agency in Mountain Top” for four years running
  • Ongoing recognition for client service excellence in Adams County

These reviews reflect the same experience you’ll have when you call, visit, or email. No outsourcing. No upselling. Just knowledgeable, kind agents who show up for their clients.

A blue and white triangle on a white background.

What Our Clients Are Saying

Jillian and her team are always great to deal with. Any questions I have on my policies are quickly answered or responded to. In this current insurance market, it is great to have this level of customer service and assistance with any policy needs. I couldn’t recommend Jillian and her team more.

Kyle H.

Luzerne County

My experience with your office has been wonderful. My experience with Farmers Fire has not. I find them difficult to deal with. The only saving grace has been working with Joy. She has always answered my questions and solved my problems. She is delightful to work with and I can always count on her to calm my fears and make everything right!! She is a true asset to your company.


Judie M.

Biglerville

Mylet & Musselman Insurance has been providing me excellent customer service with complete satisfaction for over a decade. I can say without question that the service they provide is unmatched. I highly recommend them for all of your insurance needs!

Frank L.

Hanover

Leave a Review

Already a client? We'd love to hear from you. Your feedback helps others in the community find an insurance agency they can trust—and it helps us continue improving our service.