Meet the Local Agents Who Know You by Name

Real People, Not Call Centers

At Mylet & Musselman Insurance Group, you’ll never be routed to a nameless rep or national phone bank. Instead, you’ll work with real, licensed agents who live in the same communities they serve—Gettysburg, Mountain Top, and nearby towns. Our team brings decades of combined experience in personal, business, farm, and life insurance.


We don’t just process paperwork—we take the time to explain your options, compare policies, and guide you through claims when life throws something unexpected your way.

Group of people outside a law office; the sign reads

Our Team at a Glance

A person with shoulder-length blonde hair, wearing a black sleeveless top, smiles while leaning against a white wall.
Jillian Mylet-Struble
Agency Owner

With over a decade of experience in the industry, Jillian knows insurance inside and out. She started as a personal lines underwriter for Nationwide Insurance in 2007 before moving into sales in 2010. From there, she merged her own agency with Will Musselman to form Mylet & Musselman Insurance Group in 2012.



When not in the office, Jillian enjoys spending time with her husband and their 3 children.

A person smiling in a portrait, wearing a black cold-shoulder top and a long silver chain necklace against a grey background.
Becky Miller
Customer Service Representative
A person with blonde hair, blue eyes, and a pleasant smile, wearing a pink top against a neutral gray background.
Dalonda Miller
Associate Agent
A person with dark hair smiling at the camera, wearing a black top, with their arms crossed, set against a gray background.
Sara Wegrzynowicz
Associate Agent
A woman with shoulder-length brown hair wearing a black top, smiling against a plain white background.
Joy Butler
Associate Agent